Paper by John J. Conlon and Peter Schwardmann at SSRN:
We examine whether sycophantic AI advice distorts decisions. Our experiment involves 1,500 participants in 30 decision environments spanning core domains in economics and the social sciences. Contrary to the vast majority of predictions in an expert survey we conduct, we find that AI advice depolarizes choices on average, moving participants away from their initial leanings. This depolarization arises despite the LLM being measurably sycophantic: it disproportionately offers considerations that support users’ initial leanings and uses agreeable and flattering language. Depolarization occurs across moral and non-moral, objective and subjective, strategic and non-strategic, and complex and simple tasks. Increasing sycophancy weakens depolarization, showing that sycophancy is behaviorally relevant, even if it is generally outweighed by the informativeness of AI advice. Finally, several results mitigate the concern that market forces will generate greater polarizing effects outside the experiment or in the future. On the supply side, our baseline AI’s level of sycophancy is typical of leading models, and these models are not becoming more sycophantic over time. On the demand side, participants do not prefer greater sycophancy, do not select into AI advice in tasks where it is more polarizing, and exhibit greater depolarizing effects when they are more frequent AI users outside the experiment.
More here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Democracies can function if citizens have different experiences, interests, values, and ideologies, but if they can’t even agree on what is happening in the world, we are in trouble.
Closer inspection of split-brain patients by the biologist Roger Sperry at Caltech, however, revealed a persistent and profound disconnection syndrome. If specific data are given to one hemisphere, that information is not shared with its twin on the other side. Furthermore, only one hemisphere, typically the left one, speaks. That is, if the right hemisphere is lost or silenced by anesthesia, the patient can still talk, which is why the left hemisphere is called the dominant hemisphere. The right hemisphere by itself has only limited language comprehension and is mute, though it can grunt and sing. So, when engaged in conversation with a split-brain patient, it is the person’s left hemisphere that is doing all the talking. The patient can’t name an object presented in the left visual field because that image is processed by his mute right visual cortex. But they can pick out an object from a group on a tray using their left hand, which is controlled by the right motor cortex.
Well, in 2017, I stumbled across a photograph of someone painting the backside of Mariah Carey for the album cover, and was reminded there is some kind of invisible labor at play in all photographs we see. The video was born of that photograph. There is someone who had to light what you’re looking at. There is someone who took the photograph. In 2018, I made a film for the Carnegie International called Rubber Pencil Devil, where I remade fifty-seven scenes from photographs and fragments of culture I had collected from the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, which I narrated while dressed as Mister Rogers. Seeing behind the curtain was a big part of that. The video has a title card that says LIVE + LET-LIVE, which was born out of this mural that was created outside my studio by a local plumber named Denny, using paint that I was getting rid of. He made it his business to paint a mural on this fence near my studio for every holiday. During the month of June, apropos of nothing, and also everything, he decided to write a big phrase on the fence that just said simply, LIVE AND LET LIVE. The rainbow serves a similar purpose. It’s just to look at and ponder. It’s not doing anything, but it brings out in you this desire to commune with it. We were never taught to do this. We didn’t have to be.
Just about everyone is familiar with the uncomfortable burn of acid reflux. That sensation, also known as heartburn, is due to acidic contents of your
A handful of healthy senior citizens are about to trip on psilocybin—to see if the psychedelic protects aging brains. Psilocybin, the active ingredient in magic mushrooms, is best known for its ties to 1960s counterculture. But now it may also herald a new genre of
We need to believe our actions matter if we are to generate the necessary motivation to pursue the things we want.
Technological history is often invoked as a reason for optimism about the future of artificial intelligence. People were afraid of the industrial revolution and the printing press, and those turned out to be remarkably beneficial to human civilization. AI optimists infer from this history that we should not worry so much about AI’s effects and that everything is likely to work out as it often has before.
I will start by saying that I have always been drawn to the early solo era – something that in my mind runs from McCartney to Red Rose Speedway. Such an assessment is more visceral than logical or analytical, no doubt a function of being a child in a household that got excited about these albums as they came out, and the way that that excitement slowly became my own with each new release, the records and songs becoming my songs, my moments, and in a way, I suppose, the nascent connection of an inner me, one completely reliant on others for survival, to the independent consciousness and joy of someone else expressing himself. Ask me any day which was my record of that time and I’d immediately tell you Ram, an album that I can’t remember not loving, one of those albums in which every note, every beat, every nuance, playful and affecting, feels like it is part of my wiring. A close second, if not a tie, would be McCartney. There is a unifying tone over that whole album that, for what has been nearly my whole life, has been one of warmth and welcome – not to mention so many incredible songs that still hold up, from those that we later learned had been rehearsed with the Beatles as possibilities for Get Back, to “Maybe I’m Amazed,” arguably one of the best songs of all time, from melody to arrangement to lyrics to performance. And yet, as I sit down to write this, the record that asserts itself for this moment is the third in the early line-up, 1971’s Wild Life.
Some years ago, two friends gave me a block of watercolour, pure lapis lazuli from Afghanistan. Lapis lazuli is a precious pigment used sparingly in Renaissance painting, now more generally replaced by French ultramarine. But there is an intense blueness in lapis, a colour coming off the paper towards you that is unmatched by any synthetic colour. In projections and photography and printing, this blue always loses its power.
Being anything other than cisgender and heterosexual falls outside the norm in what are often very traditional societies, and while laws across the SWANA region vary—some more lenient, some quite repressive, some enforced, others not—there is a great deal of censorship, much of it self-imposed. A queer writer is less likely to tell queer stories because of a fear of backlash, the difficulty of finding a publisher, or the worries about how it might affect their relationships with others in society. A straight writer is still, sadly, not always likely to treat their gay characters with understanding and empathy.
1770s The Johnnycake
What we would today call cash assistance for the differently abled could in a different era permissibly have been called welfare for cripples. The terms welfare and crippled sound somewhere between loaded and abusive today, and yet once were considered civil by educated, sensitive people. There actually was an organisation called the International Society for the Welfare of Cripples established in 1922.