The Guilty and the Responsible
by Chris Horner Where all are guilty, no one is; confessions of collective guilt are the best possible safeguard against the discovery of culprits, and the very magnitude of the crime the best excuse for doing nothing. – Hannah Arendt. The quotation from Arendt is often thought to apply to the aftermath of the events…
The International Patriot
by Chris Horner How should people on the ‘progressive’ side of politics view patriotism? That question continues to vex those who would connect with what they suppose are the feelings of the bulk of the population. The answer will vary a good deal according to which country we are considering – the French left, for instance,…
The Valet and His Hero
by Christopher Horner When the legend becomes fact, print the legend. —The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (dir. John Ford) No man is a hero to his valet. —proverb The highest act of reason…is an aesthetic act. —Holderlin (attrib) Sometimes it seems that growing up and learning things is one long process of disillusionment. Dis-illusion:…
The Insufficiencies of Liberalism
by Chris Horner The world we live in is changing, and our politics must change with it. We are in what has been called the ‘anthropocene’: the period in which human activity is threatening the ecosystem on which we all depend. Catastrophic climate change threatens our very survival. Yet our political class seems unable to…
Truth, Lies and Pragmatism
by Chris Horner I won that election —Donald J Trump The truth is out there —X files There is a story that Clemenceau, the Prime Minister of France, was in conversation with some German representatives during the Paris peace negations in 1919 that led to the Treaty of Versailles. One of the Germans said something…
From ‘The Queen’s Gambit’ to ‘Succession’: Reading the Themes
by Chris Horner Two series have been streaming recently, to considerable success – The Queen’s Gambit (a Netflix miniseries, now concluded) and Succession (HBO, two series so far and more planned). They are interesting for a number of reasons – both for what they show, and perhaps more for what they do not, possibly cannot,…
Reclaiming Freedom
Bloc Thinking
by Chris Horner Not long ago there was an article circulating on Facebook about ‘Hating the English’, originally published in a large circulation newspaper. The Irish author says something to the effect that once she thought it was just a few bad ones etc., but now she hates the lot of them. It’s been stimulated, I…
Demanding Democracy
by Chris Horner In the presidential election of 2016, around 45% of adult eligible to vote in the USA did not vote. It isn’t disputed that voter suppression, disproportionately affecting people of colour, was one of the causes. Another seems to be a cynicism, or apathy about the process itself. And there may be other…
The Promise of Happiness
by Chris Horner Beauty is nothing more than the promise of happiness —Stendhal How can beauty promise happiness? And what kind of beauty would this be? What sort of happiness? Happiness and Beauty have been central issues for thinkers since antiquity, and the question of what they really are, and whether we should even prize…
Tax and the Ethical Community
Moral Relativism and the Concrete Universal
by Chris Horner There are some notions, ideas and arguments, that no matter how often they are exposed as fallacious, are rebutted and refuted, seem to recur again and again. Moral relativism is one of them.[1] Put simply, this is the view that one’s moral judgments are delimited by the culture or period in which…
A Shift In The Ethical Ground
by Chris Horner There are times when customary evils become outlandish and intolerable. Then there is a call for irreversible ethical change, a transformation of more than the way we judge this or that, times in which which old laws are struck down and new ones framed. I want to suggest that a change in…
Value, Merit and Desert
by Christopher Horner It’s only when the tide goes out that you learn who has been swimming naked —Warren Buffett Buffett’s famous remark has usually been applied to the shock of the 2008 financial crisis: the over-leveraged, the under-financed, the chancers and the over-exposed in general were embarrassed when the tide went out and left…
Politics and the Beautiful Soul
by Christopher Horner If you want to deserve Hell, you need only stay in bed. The world is iniquity; if you accept it, you are an accomplice, if you change it you are an executioner. —Jean-Paul Sartre We need to learn, or re-learn, how to build comradeship and solidarity instead of doing capital’s work for…
Morbid Symptoms: COVID-19 and Pathologies in the Body Politic
by Chris Horner The crisis consists precisely in the fact that the old is dying and the new cannot be born; in this interregnum a great variety of morbid symptoms appear. —Gramsci Does a crisis show us what we are ‘really like’? Whether it does or not, it has already been instructive to experience this one,…
Liberalism and our Present Discontents
by Chris Horner The political philosophy, and more importantly, political practice that took root in the wake of the ‘Age of Revolutions’ (say 1775-1848) was liberalism of various kinds: a commitment to certain principles and practices that eventually came to seem, like any successful ideology, a kind of common sense. With this, however, came a…
Hannah Arendt and the Lost Treasure of the American Revolution
by Chris Horner In May 1919 the remains of a woman were fished from the Landwehr canal in Berlin. The three doctors available must have suspected the identity of the corpse, as they refused to perform a post mortem on it. Identification was in any case made by examination of the clothes on the body.…
