Notes on Living Through Uncertainty

Maria Popova at The Marginalian:

There are times in life when the continent of certainty parts underfoot and, as the ash cloud of the old world rains darkness upon us, we are asked to swim in the rivers of lava that will make the new. “Almost it would appear that it is useless in such confusion to ask,” wrote Virginia Woolf of such times, “those questions as to what, and why, and wherefore.” Unlike her staunchly secularized contemporaries, who shuddered to speak of the soul for fear of being seen as anti-intellectual, Woolf devoted her life to communicating from and with “all these wayward parts that constitute the human soul,” which she knew lives on a level deeper than the self to make us who we are. It is what is left to us and of us in those volcanic times of darkness and uncertainty. It is what rebuilds the world, within and without, and what always has. It is the world. We still use Kepler’s laws of planetary motion to land rovers on Mars, but we are yet to catch up to his model of the world as an ensouled body — a notion dating back to Plato, whose political precepts we still use and whose concept of anima mundi, or “world soul,” we are yet to heed.

more here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

America Must Win Back Its Global Standing

Gordon Brown in Time Magazine:

“From this day forward, a new vision will govern our land,” President Donald Trump declared in his inaugural address in January 2017. “From this moment on, it’s going to be America First.” An insular, populist nationalism, coupled with an antipathy toward globalist ideas and institutions, became the central theme and the clarion call of both his terms in the White House.

President Trump has spent considerable energy lambasting the United Nations, an institution the United States helped create 80 years ago and has shaped ever since. He has derided it as an “unelected, unaccountable, global bureaucracy,” and little more than “a talking shop.”

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

the science of critical thinking

Helen Pearson in Nature:

Yan, who teaches at Tsinghua University in Beijing, China, was using an agentic AI called Codex to set up an online course on a learning-management platform. But it quickly became clear that the adept AI could independently complete all the assignments, answer questions and participate in discussions, “without the learner being intellectually engaged” at all, Yan says.

The experience made Yan think that teaching students to reason and think for themselves “is more critical than ever”, he says. And he is hardly alone. In a 2025 survey of more than 1,000 US faculty members, conducted by the American Association of Colleges and Universities, 90% said they thought that generative AI will reduce students’ critical-thinking skills. Around 20% of higher-education students who use AI said that they already find it harder to work through problems without it, according to more than 8,000 respondents to a global survey this year.

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Cicero And Probabilia

Massimo Pigliucci at Aeon Magazine:

How tightly should you hold your beliefs? You face the question several times a week without noticing. Hold them too loosely and you don’t stand for anything, hold them too tightly and you become the sort of person no argument can reach. Most of us swing between the two and have no vocabulary for the ground in between. A Roman lawyer worked one out, under pressure far worse than anything we are likely to face, and it is still the best answer available.

The time is early 45 BCE, the place a villa near Lucrine Lake, northwest of Naples, in southern Italy. One of the most fascinating and controversial figures in the entirety of Western history, Marcus Tullius Cicero, is finishing writing a book that will be known as the Academica, where he explains the nature of sceptical philosophy and why it is so crucial not just to the advancement of human knowledge, but to living a good life. It is a strange moment to retire into one’s villa to write. The Roman Republic, so beloved by Cicero, is about to be destroyed by aspiring autocrats: Julius Caesar, a longtime friend and now a political opponent, has declared himself dictator for life, a move that will soon lead to his assassination on the Ides of March 44 BCE.

more here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Wednesday Poem

Late September

Now the wind chimes are chiming earlier,
chiming colder in the neighborhood;
the sun is smaller and the birds are fewer,
much fewer in the backyard. Now the air
is darker; my garden plots are empty.
Now I sleep with the windows closed,
and wake to silence. Then what is there?
Only thoughts: soon the pines will be
dropping needles; soon snow will be
visible on the peaks, then more snow
will silence the town—just the sound
of the wind moving through bare trees,
the sadness of a January sky. Perhaps
there are thoughts pushing toward
summer (always there are thoughts), but
where else to go when the wind chimes
begin chiming earlier, chiming colder,
when the sun suddenly grows smaller,
if not for thinking of the smell of the soil
after a June rain, picturing the tomatoes
vivid in the sunlight, or imagining opening
the screen door and stepping out into
the garden, only to find oneself lost
in a crowd of bright orange marigolds?

by Jodi Hollander
from The New Yorker. 9/21/26

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Tuesday, September 22, 2026

The problem(s) with utilitarianism

Noah Smith at Noahpinion:

Much to my amusement, the world seems to have discovered Effective Altruism. As the debate over AI safety and AI regulation has heated up, the national press is finally paying attention to the odd cultural bubble within the tech industry and tech-related circles of San Francisco Bay Area culture that produced much of the thinking on the topic up until now. For many years, Effective Altruism — or EA, as it’s known1 — was a cross between a Berkeley technohippie cult and a fun intellectual sideshow that offered nerds a pleasant distraction from whatever people in mainstream politics were yelling at each other about.

Part of that involved thinking a lot about the future of artificial intelligence, and a lot of the tech people who would end up working at AI companies — especially Anthropic — were very influenced by those discussions. So now that AI is the most important thing in the world, people in the outside world are discovering this strange little corner of our culture for the first time, and it’s very amusing to watch. You have mainstream news outlets publishing things like “This well-meaning ideology fueling AI panic has a dark side”, “How Effective Altruism Took Over the World”, “The Dangerous Ideology Behind the AI Warnings”, and so on.

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Our brain evolved from two primitive nervous systems that merged

Alice Klein at New Scientist:

Our brain may be a hybrid of two ancient nervous systems that were packaged together hundreds of millions of years ago. This is based on the finding that the front and back brain regions in people and several other species develop from two distinct cell types in embryos, instead of sharing the same developmental origin, as previously thought.

“Our research suggests that evolution took two existing neural systems and pushed them together spatially,” says Kyle Loh at Stanford University in California. “Having the brain as one organ would probably be more efficient, but we rely on this primordial way to make the brain as two separate pieces.”

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Hearing Gould

Alan Jacobs at the Hedgehog Review:

My friend Elizabeth Corey, a pianist as well as a political philosopher, tells me, “You can’t unhear Gould.” A simple but important statement. The music of Canadian pianist Glenn Gould (1932–1982) is so distinctive, so memorable, even today so surprising, that once experienced, it stays in your mind and can easily become the frame of reference by which you evaluate other pianists.

This is true even when you think someone else plays certain pieces of music better than Gould does. If I could listen to only one pianist play Bach, it would be Murray Perahia, not Gould. But when I first heard Perahia’s Bach, I had been listening to Gould’s Bach for a quarter of a century, so that for every minute in which I am lost in Perahia’s playing, there is a second in which I think, Hmmm, Gould wouldn’t have played it that way. And even when I say that to praise Perahia, which is usually the case, Gould remains the benchmark for my judgments. This is equally true when I listen to András Schiff or Jeremy Denk.

more here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

The Cauldron: The Making of the Modern Middle East

Malise Ruthven at Literary Review:

A highly readable gallop through one of the world’s most complex political environments, The Cauldron is brilliant on narrative, weaker on analysis. Simon Sebag Montefiore has set himself a formidable task: to compress the modern history of a region extending from Morocco to Iran, and from the fall of the Ottoman Empire to the wars of 2026, into a single volume. The result is an exuberant pageant of sultans, shahs, kings, colonels, spies, revolutionaries and assassins. Few historians could move so confidently from the salons of Cairo to the palaces of Riyadh, from Atatürk’s Ankara to Khomeini’s Najaf, while keeping so many figures vividly in play.

Montefiore writes in a witty, engaging, conversational style. He relishes the pungent phrase and compromising anecdote: Churchill puffs his cigar in front of the pious Saudi king, saying that his rule in life ‘prescribes an absolutely sacred rite of smoking cigars and drinking alcohol before, after and during all meals’; ‘Hassan’, says the last shah of Iran of his Moroccan fellow monarch, ‘spends half his time asleep and the rest of it buried between the legs of the fairer sex.’

more here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

‘Musk’ film is almost four hours long, engrossing and terrifying

Travis M. Andrews in The Washington Post:

The filmmaker, once described by Esquire as “becoming the most important documentarian of our time,” has tackled Enron, Eliot Spitzer, Vladimir Putin and Elizabeth Holmes. Now, he’s turned his eyes to the richest man in the history of the world.

The 3-hour-and-45-minute “Musk” (plus a 10-minute intermission) hits theaters on Oct. 16, but it’s already causing a stir.

The documentary, which spans from his early Silicon Valley days through his Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) dalliances and Twitter acquisition to his ascent to becoming the world’s first trillionaire, paints Musk as an emotionally unstable grifter with more power and influence than perhaps any other human who has ever lived.

Gibney pulls no punches, neither in the documentary nor in interviews about it, in which he’s called Musk’s power and influence “extremely dangerous to world democracy.”

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Tuesday Poem

Dream Father

I seem to have a dream about my father roughly once a year.
Most of the time he acts pretty much like when he was alive,
Stands off to one side and maintains a running commentary,
Sucking in smoke as he laughs, then exhaling it as he speaks.
It is hard for me to gauge his attitude toward life and death.
At times he seems to ask, How can I be dead if we are here?
But that may be more of a waking thought about the dream.
My dreaming self is wiser than to have that kind of thought.
My dream self is with him already and wants that to persist.
There is a certain white ribbed sweater he wore all the time.
He is always wearing it in these dreams, I only just realized,
A cheap sweater from the huge department store at the mall.
It started to pill as soon as he got it but looked good on him.
There we stand, in a field, or in the corner at a strange party.
He knows about life and feels for me that I’m still here in it,
But I wouldn’t say he’s bitter, or that he regrets his own run.
Honestly, these conversations only ever last about a minute.
We never say goodbye or tie things off, but, then, we didn’t.

John Jeremiah Sullivan
from, The Yale Review


Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

How to Govern the Existential Risk of AI

From Time Magazine:

The current state of paralysis when it comes to the governance of frontier AI technology is causing tangible harm today and raising the odds of catastrophe tomorrow.

That paralysis has been excused by a dangerous set of narratives: that the technology moves too fast for oversight, that companies can self-regulate, and that in a contest between the U.S. and China, public safety can wait. Governments have struggled to give AI risks the attention they demand. Many are wary of acting alone amid both great power rivalry and intra-industry arms race dynamics. In this context, every call for restraint meets the same reply: why should we slow down if our competitor will not?

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

A Human Bone Marrow-On-a-Chip Unveils Long-Lived Plasma Cell Behavior

Shelby Bradford in The Scientist:

When a pathogen or other antigen activates a B cell, the cell begins proliferating and producing antibodies. Once the immune response resolves, most of the B cells die off, but some migrate to the bone marrow to persist as long-lived antibody secreting plasma cells. While researchers knew that this process occurred, studying the cellular and molecular interactions in human bone marrow is difficult because of the inability to easily see the niche within the bone. Although animal and two-dimensional cell culture models have provided some insights, scientists sought to explore a more realistic human bone marrow niche.1,2

To do this, researchers at Georgia Institute of Technology and Vanderbilt University developed a human bone marrow-on-a-chip (BMOC) platform that recreated the cellular niches of this site.3 In a study published in Science Advances, the team used this system to explore the migration and localization of plasma cells in the human bone marrow.4 They showed that, while these cells remain in the bone marrow after migration, they continue to move within the niche. Additionally, the team identified important signals for the proper localization and retention of antibody secreting cells to the bone marrow, revealing the details of how these long-lived cells are maintained. This platform could help scientists better understand long-term immunity and the factors that influence certain diseases related to the bone marrow.

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Monday, September 21, 2026

Annie Dillard died this week. But her voice — wild and holy and hilarious — continues to live in my head, my soul, and somehow, my dog

NOTE: Annie Dillard was a great supporter of 3QD for the last many, many years!

Sam Anderson in the New York Times:

Dillard was undistillable. But one of her major lessons, the bass note anchoring every chord she played, is simple. She was here to remind us that, if you really look hard, nothing is boring, nothing is normal — not mothers, fathers, bicycles, cities, beetles, weasels or rocks. She would fling her awareness out into the world like an extremely eccentric hawk, letting us marvel at its loops and dives before she called it back home.

She was a sort of drill sergeant of human consciousness: determined, always, to force herself, and others, to see.

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Learning without a brain – how bacteria store memories and remember the past like artificial neural networks

Shiladitya Banerjee at The Conversation:

Learning is often thought to require a brain. But learning is a broad concept that does not necessarily depend on neurons.

If an organism uses information from past experiences to shape its future decisions, it is also learning.

Research from my lab, published in the journal PRX Life, shows that even a single bacterium can learn from experience, store memories of the past and use those memories to prepare for the future.

Bacteria live in environments that change constantly and on many different timescales. In the human gut, for example, nutrient levels go up and down, temperatures shift and antibiotic threats come and go.

To survive, a bacterium has to respond quickly to what is happening right now while still preserving useful information about what it recently experienced. Adapting too quickly leaves the bacterium vulnerable to changing conditions, while forgetting too readily makes it unable to anticipate a recurring threat.

How does a bacterium manage this balancing act?

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Mahmoud Khalil, the Palestinian Columbia student snatched by ICE, writes about his Kafkaesque ordeal with a quiet fury

Houman Barekat in The Guardian:

Mahmoud Khalil was completing a master’s degree at Columbia University when, in March 2025, plain-clothed officers from the Department of Homeland Security snatched him from his home in New York and took him to an immigration detention centre; he was then transferred to another facility in Louisiana, more than 1,000 miles away. As a green card holder, Khalil has permanent US residency, but secretary of state Marco Rubio had determined that his continued presence in the country would have “adverse foreign policy consequences for the United States”, and sought his deportation under a legal provision dating back to the McCarthy era. Khalil was released on bail in June 2024 after a federal judge ruled his detention unconstitutional, but the Trump administration is still trying to have him removed.

Khalil – who was born to Palestinian parents in a refugee camp in Syria – had been targeted because of his advocacy on behalf of pro-Palestinian protesters during campus protests over Columbia University’s links to Israel. They were calling for Columbia to cut its ties with Israeli academic institutions and companies profiting from Israel’s onslaught on Gaza; in response, the university called in the NYPD. There was no suggestion that Khalil had done anything unlawful, and no criminal charges were brought against him; the government had simply identified him as an influential pro-Palestinian voice on campus, and for that reason alone they wanted him gone. He spent a total of 104 days in detention, missing the birth of his son.

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.