Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Category: Recommended Reading
2026 Nobel Laureate Anne Carson: Life is Not Fair
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
A Nobel for New Keynesian macro, at last!
Noah Smith at Noahpinion:
First, let me say that this prize is long overdue. In 2009, I asked my PhD advisor, Miles Kimball, who was the greatest living macroeconomist. Without hesitation, he answered “Bob Hall”, and said he would be very surprised if Hall didn’t win the Nobel at some point. Hall’s work is breathtakingly broad; if you want good summaries, I recommend Alex Tabarrok and Tyler Cowen (as usual). As for Michael Woodford, everyone I know assumed that if New Keynesian macro ever did get the prize, Woodford would be included, as he literally wrote the book on it.
But anyway, let’s talk about New Keynesian economics — what it is, how it came about, why it’s important, and why it didn’t get a Nobel until now. Let’s start with a brief history of modern macroeconomics.
More here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Tuesday Poem
How Facebook Escaped Harvard
Noam Cohen in Harvard Magazine:
Kevin Davis ’98 remembers walking into Harvard’s Science Center one winter morning and taking the stairs down to the computer lab, a large, windowless room in the basement where about 100 terminals were arranged in neat rows, separated by glass dividers, each with its own rolling office-style chair. The chairs were filled with undergraduates, and out of the corner of his eye, Davis noticed that nearly half of their screens were casting the same blue and white flickering lights. He thought to himself, “That’s weird, because all these students are usually doing their assignments, checking their email.” When Davis reached the student help desk, which he managed as the University’s supervisor of student and residential computing, he realized that the members of the tech support team were no different. Everyone was looking at the same website at the same time.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
How Healthy Is Broccoli?
Caroline Hopkins Legaspi in The New York Times:
Ever scrunched up your nose at broccoli’s sulfuric smell?
Along with cauliflower, brussels sprouts and other cruciferous vegetables, broccoli is a source of a sulfur-based nutrient called sulforaphane. It’s the compound behind broccoli’s odor and slightly bitter flavor. It also has anticancer properties, scientists believe. Research suggests the sulforaphane in broccoli could help your body produce more of the enzymes that get rid of toxins like air pollution and cigarette smoke, Dr. Ho said.
In addition, sulforaphane is an antioxidant that can protect your body from inflammation. The theory “is that broccoli is protecting cells from the inflammation that promotes the growth of cancer,” said Ingrid Adams, a registered dietitian and associate professor of medical dietetics at Ohio State University. In a recent analysis, 17 out of 23 studies found associations between eating broccoli and having lower risks of common cancers, including lung, colon and breast cancer. Taken together, the studies suggested that people who ate broccoli at least once a week were 36 percent less likely to develop cancer than those who didn’t.
More here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Monday, October 12, 2026
Birth order doesn’t predict your personality but here’s what does
Michael J. Coren at the Washington Post:
Many of us assign personality traits to the family pecking order: the bossy firstborn, the peacekeeping middle child, and, woe to us all, the reckless youngest.
When researchers test such tidy predictions, analyzing the statistical souls of millions of people, they have reached the same conclusion: Birth order has no durable predictive power over your personality. When it comes to foreseeing your future, it’s about as good as astrology.
Your rank in the birth lineup can shape your life. It just doesn’t define the unique combination of thoughts, feelings and behaviors that make you who you are. As I’ve written, younger siblings fare worse, on average, than firstborns across a range of metrics, including lifetime earnings and educational achievement. That’s because differences in quality time with parents and, perhaps to a greater degree, serious respiratory infections shape a child’s development in ways that reverberate through the decades.
Could there be more?
More here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Scott Aaronson on the Mathocalypse
Scott Aaronson at Shtetl-Optimized:
No, I’m not aware of any direct practical implications of any of these results. I certainly don’t expect the O(n log0.9999999999999 n)-time Fourier Transform algorithm to get practically deployed anytime soon! But anyone who harps on this, simply doesn’t understand what mathematical progress looks like, or how it eventually pulls the rest of science and technology and human civilization with it. If and when the relevant human mathematicians understood the clever new ideas in all 372 of these papers, I have no doubt that they’d be able to use the ideas to do all sorts of new things, and that some of those things would have practical value. That’s yet another reason to try to keep human understanding at the center of our enterprise—unless, of course, you’re happy to outsource the task of understanding and applying the ideas to AI models as well.
Meanwhile, something calling itself the Association for Human Mathematics put out a statement condemning OpenAI for its release. The statement included a sentence that’s since been widely mocked on social media: “Mathematicians did not ask for this work to be done.” (Imagine G. H. Hardy saying to Ramanujan, “who asked you to prove all these bizarre new identities?”)
If it wasn’t clear, the members of AHM speak for themselves, not for the math community as a whole.
More here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Helion CEO David Kirtley on why fusion finally works
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Dua Lipa & Lea Ypi On Freedom, Communism And Growing Up In Albania
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
She’s Been to Gaza. She Met With the Iranians. Now She Has a Warning.
Lulu Garcia-Navarro in the New York Times:
Are we already in the middle of a new world war without realizing it? That’s the provocative question I wanted to explore when I sat down with someone in the rare position to know: Mirjana Spoljaric, the head of the International Committee of the Red Cross.
The I.C.R.C. is a secretive organization that is not well known outside war zones. Unlike the American Red Cross, which deals with blood drives and American disaster relief, the I.C.R.C. is the independent and neutral guardian of the Geneva Conventions, a series of international agreements created in the wake of World War II that laid out the rules of war. In her role, Spoljaric travels to all sides of active war zones — Gaza, Ukraine, Iran — meeting with the heads of governments and armed groups alike. She rarely gives interviews because of the politically fraught and confidential nature of her work, but she sat down with me just after the most recent U.N. General Assembly because she is deeply worried about not only the growing number of conflicts in the world but also how complex they have become.
More here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Lea Ypi’s Genre-Blending Histories
Santiago Ramos at Commonweal:
When the pandemic began, Albanian philosopher Lea Ypi decided to use her time in lockdown to try something new. Instead of the big academic book about the meaning of freedom that she had been planning to write, she composed a memoir about growing up during the collapse of Communism in Albania. “Mostly written from a closet in Berlin,” as she would later put it, her book Free: Coming of Age in the End of History was her attempt “to muse about my grandmother’s words: ‘When it’s difficult to see clearly into the future, you have to think about what you can learn from the past.’” Free became a bestseller, and now we have the follow-up: a unique blend of fiction and family history titled Indignity: A Life Reimagined.
Ypi made the right choice: these beautiful books are more compelling, and will reach a wider audience, than any scholarly work on the same themes. Through the implications of narrative rather than philosophical argument, both books confront the famous idea referenced in Free’s subtitle: Francis Fukuyama’s “End of History.”
more here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Napoleon and his Marshals
Jonathan Boff at Literary Review:
The tale of the unknown Corsican soldier who rose from nothing to the throne of France, and conquered Europe from the Pyrenees to the gates of Moscow, only to lose it all, is an epic of such drama that, in over two hundred years, only one person has managed to make it boring. Heaven knows how Ridley Scott managed it. Andrew Roberts does a much better job with this new book, which rattles along like a gun carriage charging into action. It is of course a familiar story, not least to Roberts himself. In 2014 he wrote Napoleon the Great, which made the case for bracketing his subject with Alexander, Peter and Frederick. That was a full biography which portrayed Napoleon in action, both on the battlefield and in the council chamber as a civilian lawgiver. It showed his genius in full context, the only way to make proper sense of his whole tragic arc, through hubris to eventual nemesis.
Napoleon and his Marshals returns to this monumental tale. The twist this time is that while of course Napoleon remains in the spotlight, he now shares the stage with the twenty-six men whom he installed as marshals of France.
more here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Why the Brain Isn’t the Self
Melanie Challenger in Undark Magazine:

For centuries, humans have sought a vital essence to explain what makes life different from the rest of matter. Therein lies one of the most persistent errors in human thought, and one that has acquired new force in an age when intelligence is increasingly imagined as something separable from biological life. At its Latin roots, consciousness literally meant “knowing with.” This was a borrowing from an earlier Proto-Indo-European verb for splitting or separating something, which gave rise, in turn, to a host of related words for division and distinction.
Consciousness, then, was to know others and thereby to know oneself. Perhaps, too, it was to know what no one else knew. And so, at its post-Aristotelian origins, to be conscious was both a differentiation of knowledge and a knowledge of difference. Potentially, consciousness might be more comprehensible, then, as a form of knowledge of the knowledge of the body.
More here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Will We Ever Understand Dementia?
Robert Kolker in The New York Times:
The story of the science of dementia began on an autumn day in 1891, when a 71-year-old man was admitted to the psychiatric hospital at the University of Prague. The man, referred to as August H. in his medical file, had periods of freezing up mentally, sometimes fainting and not coming to for several minutes. More recently, he had been prone to fits of rage, and even threatened his wife with a knife, shouting that he was going to kill her.
The case caught the attention of the director of the clinic, Arnold Pick. After August H. died, Pick’s team examined his brain, dividing it into sections and weighing them and checking for abnormalities. The brain seemed essentially normal except for signs of decay, or atrophy, in one self-contained place: the left temporal lobe.
This was quite likely the first recorded moment that a scientist, staring at a piece of brain tissue, saw dementia as a problem to be understood and solved, rather than a natural, unavoidable part of aging. Until then, almost everyone, including Pick himself, had taken it as an article of faith that dementia, or senility, was a generalized condition, the sign of a brain in overall decline. But after seeing August H.’s brain, Pick began to search for and document other dementia cases in which the problem wasn’t aging, but this specific part of the brain that was starting to lose function and misfire.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Sunday, October 11, 2026
Sunday Poem
A Kind of Biography
All night the language dog
gnaws at the meaning bone.
Soon the sea begins
to question its shuffling
from East to West, and the stars
their vast, ordinary ciruits.
So my friend has fled into his father’s fields.
He leans against a fence
and wonders what the ant means
and the moonlit grasses as they bend
and spread and flow beneath
a wind whose beginning seems obscure
and whose end, uncertain.
He notices that something of himself
has set off with the wind
and that he is now two.
He wonders at the doubleness.
Back home, he sits in the kitchen,
an ordinary boy watching
his mother cook breakfast,
but something of him is in
another place, and some other thing
is with him even here.
by Nils Peterson
from The dear Time of our Talking
Frog on the Moon Small Press,
Cupertino, Ca. 2020
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Cry to the Angels
Marigold Warner in lensculture:
In search of a feeling of youth she encountered online, Avery Norman constructs an imaginary girlhood informed by a combination of cultural iconography, Internet nostalgia, and personal memory.
If you were a certain kind of girl on the Internet in the 2010s, Avery Norman’s images are likely to feel familiar. Her series Cry To The Angels explores the “aesthetics and emotional architecture” of an imagined girlhood, carrying flickers of the romantic melancholy that surged through platforms like Tumblr and Myspace—images which Norman summarizes as “girls looking sad and bored in beautiful and run down places.”
The resulting images are entirely fictional, informed by a combination of “cultural iconography, Internet nostalgia and personal memory.” Born in 2000 in Houston, Norman’s coming-of-age was positioned at an interesting time for the Internet and social media.
More here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
50 Years Later, a Hit Book on Women’s Sexuality Deserves Some Love
Alexandra Jacobs in The New York Times:
In the Battle of the Sexologists, Alfred Kinsey probably wins: He was played by an A-list movie star. Masters and Johnson got a Showtime series. Having survived the Holocaust, Dr. Ruth lived long enough to podcast. Shere Hite? Even those who remember her influential book “The Hite Report,” a crowdsourced account of female sexuality published 50 years ago this month, are not 100 percent sure how to pronounce her first name: like Sherry but without the “y.”
One could be forgiven for assuming instead a charactonym, “sheer height,” that conjures both her champagne achievement — she popped noisily, then fizzled — and the plastic-shelled L’eggs pantyhose of her heyday. The “Report” is one of the best-selling nonfiction books of all time, having sold some 50 million copies, but a weird layer of disrepute — like the Saran Wrap women were once advised to wear when welcoming their husbands home — clings to its auburn-tressed author, who died at 77 in 2020.
More here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Anwar Shaikh (1945–2026)
Vivek Chibber in Jacobin:
With the passing of Anwar Shaikh, the left intellectual community has lost one of its most dynamic and brilliant members. Anwar was not just a leading light among heterodox economists; he was the most brilliant Marxist economist of his generation and arguably the most important since Karl Marx himself. He did more than perhaps any other contemporary economist to revive the classical tradition in political economy, associated with Adam Smith, David Ricardo, and Marx. He then brought that framework to bear on the more short-term dynamics analyzed by the Keynesian tradition, showing that classical economic theory was capable of analyzing the same phenomena and integrating the two into one encompassing framework. And if that was not enough, he accomplished the herculean task of operationalizing Marxian categories to show how the empirical regularities of modern capitalism were governed by the mechanisms that Marx described in the volumes of Capital. In the history of Marxian economics, it is doubtful that there has been any other figure who did more to advance its agenda and put it on a secure footing.
Shaikh was born in Karachi, Pakistan, in 1945. But because his father was in the Pakistani Foreign Service, he spent many of his formative years in the Middle East, Southeast Asia, and Turkey. He completed his higher education in the United States with a degree in engineering from Princeton in 1965 and then an economics PhD from Columbia University in 1973. This meant, of course, that he was at the epicenter of the student movements of the time — antiwar, civil rights, and feminist. Like many of the most talented students of his generation, he was radicalized into Marxism and dedicated his singular talents to developing Marxist economic theory.
More here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
Fifteen Years Later
Javier Moreno Zacarés in Sidecar:
Fifteen years after the indignados occupied the Puerta del Sol, Madrid’s central plaza is once again the locus of a mass movement that has brought Spain to a political impasse. How are we back here again? The immediate trigger was the eviction of an elderly tenant. Maricarmen Abascal, who had occupied her rent-capped apartment in central Madrid since 1956, was expelled from her home on 23 September after the investment fund Urbagestión acquired the property and exploited a legal loophole to quintuple her rent. Maricarmen’s age and vulnerability – the 87-year-old was removed on a hospital bed and has since died – made it a particularly egregious breach of the moral economy. The case struck a nerve, prompting a political storm; the government has now announced a snap election. As protests spread nationwide, the encampment at Puerta del Sol consolidated under the leadership of the Sindicato de Inquilinas, Madrid’s tenant union. Media outlets are reporting on the motions passed at the open-air general assembly. One decision has been of particular public interest: a general strike for the right to housing, announced for 11 November, a few weeks before the election.
The political elite faces a reckoning. At the outset of the current parliamentary term in 2023, the progressive coalition headed by Sánchez’s centre-left Socialist Party (PSOE) placed housing at the top of the agenda. The promises were ambitious: the provision of mass social housing, the imposition of rent controls, the reassertion of the public interest against rentier logics. Yet these commitments yielded little. This was partly due to the obstruction of the right, both in parliament and in the regional governments under its control. But a share of the blame lies in the ambivalence of the Socialist Party itself, whose ministers have repeatedly expressed discomfort with what they regard as excessive regulation of housing.
More here.
Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.
