Writing “That” Essay

by Andrea Scrima

In many ways I was lucky: I was neither raped, trafficked, nor bitten on the genitals so hard that I bled, an image that emerged from a trove of emails recently released from the Epstein files detailing alleged acts of abuse by billionaire Leon Black, who was forced to step down as chairman of the Board of Trustees of the Museum of Modern Art in New York in 2021. I wasn’t groped or forced to undress or perform a sexual act on myself or my predator. I’d incurred no physical injuries or bruises; the damage he did was of a different kind.

When his name turned up recently, attached to a prestigious new prize for young artists, I was sure I was mistaken; after a quick internet search revealed that it was, in fact, the same man, it took me some time to process the discovery. From one moment to the next, I found myself staring at the college graduation photograph of a man I’d done my best to forget, and although he was in his late thirties when I met him, I recognized the face immediately. I was an eighteen-year-old painting major writing long-form poetry, he was the head of the poetry seminar I wanted more than anything to get into. I see him standing opposite me in a turtleneck sweater. He’d already heaped praise on my work; he had, in fact, chosen me from that year’s crop of young art students. Not as a prodigy to mentor, as I would soon discover, but as a sexual interest. When I turned down his advances, he refused to let me into the class.

He’s been dead for three or four years now; a rather sizeable legacy funds at least two major awards in his name: one in the visual arts, the other in literature. Staring at his obituary, trying to make sense of my emotions, I was haunted by memories I hadn’t had access to in decades. I let a few days pass, and then I mailed an editor at an art magazine I work with, briefly outlined what happened, and asked if this was just another one of those countless #MeToo stories and if there was any point in writing it—as far as pitches go, it was hesitant, reluctant. As it turns out, there are several fairly serious sexual abuse scandals connected to the art school I was enrolled in at the time, and so the editors were indeed interested and I did, in fact, wind up writing the piece, which will be published in the aforementioned magazine in March. But this essay is a different essay, one about writing that essay: the uncertainty that suddenly nagged at me, the sense of not being believed or even particularly believable, the lingering feeling of shame that nearly all victims of sexual predation carry with them, years and even decades later. Read more »

Thursday, January 16, 2025

The Normalization of Sexual Violence

by Andrea Scrima

1. Bloodthirsty

Swedish journalist Kim Wall in a 2015 portrait taken in Trelleborg. Wall died aboard Danish inventor Peter Madsen’s submarine.

I have a morbid personality; sometimes I stay up late at night, googling serial killers and rapists. In the light of the computer screen, scrolling through articles on websites published by amateur sleuths, I feel the dark pull of the unspeakable deed. But my fascination isn’t for the blood and gore; there is no thrill bubbling up inside, no voyeuristic kick. Nor am I moved by an urge to understand the killers’ psychological predicament or the geometry of their desire. The pull I feel is not toward their person or otherwise banal lives, but that point of no return when the not-yet-killer gives in to the irresistible urge, forfeits his allegiance to society, and defects to the other side. How strong does that urge have to be?

I worry. The brain is an organ, it’s unreliable, prone to illness; a sick brain thinks sick thoughts. There was a point in the killer’s life, I think, when he or she hadn’t yet committed the crime, a point when it would have been possible to stop and reflect on the inevitable consequences—not a life of adventure and freedom, but the monotony of prison, of incarceration and boredom, isolation, enforced celibacy. Could this happen to me—could something push me over that tipping point, and I’d find myself a moment later in a foreign land? I am horrified by physical violence; a bloody scene in a movie makes me turn my head away. The mirror neurons in my body tingle in response when I see someone else’s wound. What happens to people who lose this visceral reaction, who grow numb and enter a realm in which the divide between the self and the other is so absolute that they live as though in a vacuum, sealed off, in communion with their darkest compulsions, indifferent to the living reality of another human being’s existence?

I scroll through reports of repulsive deeds: the Danish inventor who murdered the young journalist who came to interview him because he was convinced that the rush he would experience at the very moment he was annihilating her would be superior to all the orgasms he’d had previously; the Coloradan who strangled his wife and smothered his two children in the expectation that the life he would then be free to live with his girlfriend could be happy and carefree, unencumbered by child support payments and filled with the real-life equivalents of the emojis and exclamation marks that decorated his love letters to her. Unremarkable, contemptible people on nearly every level. In the first case: megalomania and a history of power issues and abusive relationships; in the second, murderous intent hidden behind a mild-mannered demeanor and a stupidity so dumbfoundingly obvious that the footage of his interrogation at the hands of a brilliant woman detective deftly guiding him toward claims that proved effortlessly refutable is almost a pleasure to watch. And yet: there’s something I’m not getting. What is it that draws me in? Read more »