Myths and Motivation

by Marie Snyder

There are contradicting views and explanations of what dopamine is and does and how much we can intentionally affect it. However, the commonly heard notions of scrolling for dopamine hits, detoxing from dopamine, dopamine drains, and craving dopamine, appear to be more like a story we’ve constructed to understand our actions than a scientific explanation, and I’m not convinced it’s the best narrative to help us change our behaviours, particularly around tech-based habits.   

As a hormone, it’s released by the adrenal glands (above the kidneys) into the bloodstream for slower, more general communications where it primarily helps to regulate our immune system. As a neurotransmitter, it provides fast, local comms between neurons in the brain where it does a lot of different things including affecting movement, memory, motivation, mood, and mornings (waking up). It makes up 80% of the “catecholamine content” in our brain, the ingredients that prepare us for action. Our levels fluctuate throughout each day, so you don’t have to try to cram all your work into the early hours of the morning. 

It’s largely discussed as the heart of our quest for pleasure, yet for decades studies have concluded that dopamine doesn’t affect pleasure, since we get a dopamine release before a rewarding activity, not after we’ve completed it. Instead, it affects how the brain decides if an action is worth the effort. A 2020 study found that increasing it with meds like Ritalin can motivate people to perform harder physical tasks. People with higher levels of dopamine are more likely to choose a harder task with a higher reward than an easier, low-reward task. Low dopamine doesn’t reduce focus, but it’s believed it provokes giving more weight to the perceived cost of an activity instead of the potential reward. Lower levels lead us to save energy. 

So why do we think we crave it or, paradoxically, need to try to intentionally deplete it?  Read more »

Dwelling in the Doing: a new year’s resolve

by Gary Borjesson

Around the new year you may, like me, be inclined to reflect on your life. And if you weren’t so inclined, the media will remind you with its best-of lists, retrospectives and prospectives. These reflections often become musings (if not resolves) about what we want to keep in our lives, what we could do without, and where we want to make changes or grow.

Which brings me to my theme, a big simple idea I find helpful, and recommend to you, when contemplating changes (including changes of attitude). It can help steady us through changes of all sorts, whether grieving a loss, struggling with our health, losing weight, starting an exercise routine or a meditation practice, embarking on a new career, or considering retirement. The idea is this: once you’re clear about what you want, focus on the activity, not the goal; the process, not the reward; the journey, not the destination.

Perhaps you find this obvious; I hope so. Still, as Orwell famously observed, “To see what is in front of one’s nose needs a constant struggle.” It’s especially easy to lose sight of the obvious when we’re met with the equally obvious, and competing, truth: that we should keep our eyes on the prize. True, it’s vital to be clear about the goal and good we are seeking. In our results-focused world, however, we hardly need this reminder. Anyway, even if all we want are results, the best way to get them is to pay attention to the process.

A story about a little ritual of friendship called “Seek!” will illustrate what I have in mind. The goal of “Seek!” is, of course, to find. In this story, the reward will be a crunchy pig’s ear, but go ahead and substitute whatever goal you please: six-pack abs, fluency in Japanese, a first novel, a kayak you built yourself, a thriving business or partnership.

Theila

The friend in this ritual is my dog Theila, who loves a crunchy chewy pig’s ear. (I know.) But I expect her to work for her reward. What I know, and think she suspects, is that the work of seeking will ultimately become the main pleasure—the journey will become the destination, which is happiness. Knowing this gives me the resolve to stick with the hard work of training her and myself in the art of seeking. In the same way, it’s easier to be patient and encouraging with ourselves when we adopt the mindset that, as hard as change is, eventually we will enjoy what now feels like work, whether it’s running, sobriety, meditation, healthy eating, etc. In the meantime, we focus not on what we seek, but on building a practice around it, trusting that results will come. Read more »