Current Affairs Is Jordan Peterson Just Making It Up as He Goes?

Luke Savage in The Walrus:

Jordan Peterson’s marketability has always been a bit surprising given his weirdness. He speaks exclusively in a glottal cadence that sounds like Kermit the Frog after a night of heavy drinking. He calls hostile interlocutors “bucko.” He breaks down in tears when discussing children’s cartoons and has occasionally been known to dress like the Joker. But these days, the reactionary right is miserably bereft of real intellectuals, and a decade or so ago, Peterson stepped into this void and was rewarded with global success.

That success, improbably, comes from a unique fusion of obscurantism and conservative pomposity. There’s a certain genre of left-coded writing, for example, that’s rightly derided for its convolution, even meaninglessness. Perhaps the most common hallmark of this style is the incessant bracketing of words in scare quotes, a tactic that often allows the author (or “author”) to assert ideas or concepts while remaining aloof and evasive about what it is they’re actually saying. Sometimes, there are random capitalizations as well, or particular sentences are italicized for no discernible reason. In this genre, everything—right down to the very act of writing itself—plays out in linguistic abstraction, and at a convenient remove from anything tangible or concrete.

More there.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Audra McDonald’s ‘Gypsy’ Showstopper Is a Revelation

Ben Brantley in The New York Times:

Eight times a week at the Majestic Theater in Manhattan, the entire, harrowing arc of a classic tragedy is delivered in 4½ minutes that are as exhilarating as they are upsetting. All the textbook components of tragedy according to Aristotle are vigorously at work here: self-delusion and self-knowledge, pity and terror, and the sense that what is happening is somehow both unexpected and inevitable.

And all of this — right down to that climactic, rushing release called catharsis — is provided, near the end of a delectably tuneful show, by a lone woman performing a single song in what is generally regarded as the cheeriest of theatrical forms, the American musical. Yet by that number’s conclusion, Audra McDonald, the Tony-nominated star of George C. Wolfe’s Broadway revival of “Gypsy,” has the flayed-skinless appearance of a figure in a Francis Bacon portrait.

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Sunday Poem

Ocean waves crashing on the world’s shores emit more PFAS into the air
than the world’s industrial polluters.The Guardian, April 19, 2024

Forever Chemicals

DuPont coats the ocean.
Stain, rain, grease-resistant PFAS
slick the tide, crash the cliffs,
catch the breeze. Lungs and leaves
vacuum the patented
miracle compounds to drift
in the vascular currents of earth
through radish roots, umbilical cords,
the baleens of whales, the soft
aspirant skin of frogs.

Chemical chains of popcorn bags
ride the rain back to the corn and crows.
Teflon slides from the skillet to the wheat
to its threshers and beetles.

Comfortable in my polyfluoroalkyl-
saturated raincoat, I balance
on salt-polished boulders that rim
the churn of the bay. Waves pull and pound.
The rocks atomize ocean to a gentle mist;
prisms shutter in the blur, gulls glide.
I breathe deeply, feel the spray and all
that it carries precipitate
into the waters of my body.

by Robbin Woolman
from Ecotheo Review

 

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Friday, June 6, 2025

3 Quarks Daily Is Looking For New Columnists

Dear Reader,

Here’s your chance to say what you want to the large number of highly educated readers that make up 3QD’s international audience. Several of our regular columnists have had to cut back or even completely quit their columns for 3QD because of other personal and professional commitments and so we are looking for a few new voices. We do not pay, but it is a good chance to draw attention to subjects you are interested in, and to get feedback from us and from our readers.

We would certainly love for our pool of writers to reflect the diversity of our readers in every way, including gender, age, ethnicity, race, sexual orientation, etc., and we encourage people of all kinds to apply. And we like unusual voices and varied viewpoints. So please send us something. What have you got to lose? Click on “Read more” below…

NEW POSTS BELOW

Read more »

Escape from Los Angeles

Katya Apekina at Alta:

I had read about the Santa Ana winds in a Joan Didion essay but had incorrectly understood them to be a mood-altering phenomenon, something with positive ions that made people feel on edge. It did not occur to me that they were a very real weather event, not just a vibe. That day, January 7, the fires had already started in the Pacific Palisades, which is more than 20 miles from Highland Park, where I live, but even so, I was not overly concerned. At my daughter’s school, they’d kept the kids inside during recess. That seemed excessive—and when my friend texted me some X account, with a crudely circled map, warning about the winds, it sounded overblown. That evening, when I walked to pick my daughter up from her class, there were gusts of wind and palm fronds littering the road. It felt spooky, but also slightly exciting. A weather event! The L.A. version of a snowstorm.

When we got home that evening, the wind picked up and began to shake our old and poorly sealed house. Our sense of excitement tilted. My daughter began to cry. A shingle flew off the roof. From the laundry room window, I could see the red glow of the Eaton Fire in the distance, then the jump of flames.

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

The Core of Fermat’s Last Theorem Just Got Superpowered

Joseph Howlett in Quanta:

In 1994, an earthquake of a proof shook up the mathematical world. The mathematician Andrew Wiles had finally settled Fermat’s Last Theorem, a central problem in number theory that had remained open for over three centuries. The proof didn’t just enthrall mathematicians — it made the front page of The New York Times(opens a new tab).

But to accomplish it, Wiles (with help from the mathematician Richard Taylor) first had to prove a more subtle intermediate statement — one with implications that extended beyond Fermat’s puzzle.

This intermediate proof involved showing that an important kind of equation called an elliptic curve can always be tied to a completely different mathematical object called a modular form. Wiles and Taylor had essentially unlocked a portal between disparate mathematical realms, revealing that each looks like a distorted mirror image of the other. If mathematicians want to understand something about an elliptic curve, Wiles and Taylor showed, they can move into the world of modular forms, find and study their object’s mirror image, then carry their conclusions back with them.

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

The End of Silicon Politics

Yascha Mounk at his Substack:

The “HUGEst” political alliance of the century is breaking apart before our eyes in suitably spectacular fashion.

For the last months, the most powerful man in the world, Donald Trump, and the richest man in the world, Elon Musk, were a political item. Musk donated large sums to Trump’s campaign, lavished the newly reelected president with praise on his social network, and neglected his companies to pursue his side quest at the helm of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE). In return, Trump gave Musk unprecedented powers over the federal bureaucracy, staged joint press conferences in the Oval Office, and allowed him to lecture the assembled cabinet before rolling cameras. Nothing better symbolized the supposed “vibe shift” in America than the fact that Trump, practically a social pariah when he was first elected to the White House, could upon his return count on the outspoken support of the world’s most famous entrepreneur—and many other leading figures in Silicon Valley.

But it was also clear from the start that the match between Musk and Trump might prove stormy. The egos of both men are evidently outsized, their temperaments famously volatile. It did not take a genius to predict that their supposedly perfect match might prove short-lived, or even that it would end in acrimony. And yet, the speed with which their epic bromance has turned into an explosive feud is astonishing.

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Friday Poem

Definitions

Behind the black outline
of a split-trunked tree,
a gray sky meets a gray sea.
It is as if heaven and sea
were one in a gray ease.

Is there no demarcation,
then, between heaven and sea,
no place where one is one
and the other, the other?

Ah, but the bright sun rises
with all its knowing, draws a line,
says, “This is the sea, that heaven,”
and we look about a world thinking
this is me, that is everything else

but remembering that moment
before the sun rose.

……………. Brahma dreams his delicious dreams
……………. between wake and sleep.  It is the world
……………. he dreams, and the stars, and all
……………. possibilities – And we the dreams dream
……………. back the dreamer, shutting his eyes
……………. and seating him cross-legged on a lotus.
……………. We dream for him our own heroes
……………. how one, at the end of a hard life of heroing,
……………. is offered heaven, but he says “No,” refusing
……………. to accept that old fracturing into heaven and hell.

by Nils Peterson

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Drawing Out Twombly

Dean Rader at the LARB:

Twombly (1928–2011) has been a polarizing figure. He is best known for his large scrawly works in grayscale, sometimes called “blackboard paintings,” that resemble the marks of a second grader trying to learn cursive and failing. The artist has drawn (ha!) admiration from some of the greatest writers and critics of our era, from Roland Barthes and Robert Motherwell to Octavio Paz and Anne Carson. Yet few artists have also been on the end of more ridicule. Donald Judd called an early exhibit of Twombly’s “a fiasco.” Jackson Arn described a Twombly series from 2003 as “too repetitively cheery to be engaging, like a bad series of children’s books.” In 1994, when the Museum of Modern Art hosted a Twombly retrospective, Artforum ran competing takes on Twombly’s oeuvre titled “Cy’s Up” and “Size Down,” in which the venerable scholar Rosalind E. Krauss and Peter Schjeldahl (who would go on to be the art critic at The New Yorker) squared off. Wading into the debate, curator Kirk Varnedoe penned “Your Kid Could Not Do This, and Other Reflections on Cy Twombly.” And exactly a decade ago, in a glowing piece in Artforum, the novelist and critic Travis Jeppesen dubbed Twombly “the greatest American painter of the twentieth century, and the greatest painter after Picasso, period.”

That is an astonishing statement. And I’m not sure he’s wrong.

more here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

The moral price tag of decency: Why 1% Might Be Enough

Michael Plant in iai:

Most of us like to see ourselves as good, morally decent individuals. What’s more, we largely agree on what it means to be a decent person. You don’t just have to pay your taxes and not harm others. You have to go beyond that by, for instance, being kind, treating others with respect, and supporting your friends, family and neighbours. What our modern secular society lacks, however, is a clear idea of how a decent person should give to charity. We live in a world of staggering inequality and extreme need. There will always be more we could do. When have we given enough – not to be a saint, but to clear the bar of decency?

One extreme view comes from the philosopher Peter Singer. In his famous thought experiment, you’re walking past a shallow pond and see a child drowning. You could save the child—but it would ruin your expensive new shoes. Most people agree that it would be wrong not to wade in. Singer proposes the principle that if we can prevent something bad from happening, without sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, we ought to do so.

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

A Nasogenital Tale

Urte Laukaityte at Aeon Magazine:

In Vienna, in late February 1895, a 30-year-old woman, Emma Eckstein, is about to undergo an operation. She has recently complained of a few health problems – mostly stomach pain and discomfort, some sadness, especially around her period. Luckily, a young Berlin doctor by the name of Wilhelm Fliess is there to help. He comes highly recommended by a long-time trusted family friend, himself a reputable physician, Sigmund Freud. They agree that Eckstein’s menstrual stomach issues can be addressed through a simple surgery on an altogether different body part – Fliess removes a bit of bone from inside her nose.

The late 19th century saw a flowering of interest in the nasogenital reflex – the idea that there is a strong physiological link between the nose and the genitals. The nasogenital concept could allegedly explain all manner of trouble, not just in the reproductive system but across the board. The nose provided a clinical shortcut of sorts, a kind of map of the body. For mild illness, treatment could involve stimulating the problem areas of the nasal mucosa with cocaine.

more here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Thursday, June 5, 2025

What a psychotherapist learned during his chats with a large language model

Robert Saltzman in The Hedgehog Review:

What does it mean to say, “I am aware,” when that sentence might be as much a performance as a report?

That is the edge we now stand on. The question is not whether AI is sentient but how the invention of such accurate, coherent, convincing mirrors reflects upon our own experience of sentience, insight, and presence. We assume a great deal about our status as self-aware beings. What if those assumptions are fashioned largely from automatic responses of which we are unaware, not so different from Claude’s unawareness of its algorithms?

Claude is not a mind. But it can demonstrate the shape of one with emptiness at its center. There is no there there.

But what of us?

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Inside the thriving wild-animal markets that could start the next pandemic

Jane Qiu in Nature:

The world is still recovering from the COVID-19 pandemic, which many researchers say probably started, or was at least amplified, at a market selling live animals in Wuhan, China1,2. Yet the wildlife trade still thrives in many parts of the globe. China banned the farming and trading of most wildlife species for food in 2020, but these practices have simply gone underground. “We are back to business as usual,” says Vincent Nijman, a conservation biologist at Oxford Brookes University, UK, with “millions and millions of animals being traded on a daily basis”.

The wildlife trade acts as a vast global network of unregulated natural laboratories, through which potential pathogens freely circulate, evolve and ultimately congregate in urban centres, says Andrew Cunningham, a wildlife epidemiologist at the Institute of Zoology in London. “It’s the scariest thing we are doing,” he says.

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.

Pirates of the Ayahuasca

Sarah Miller at n+1:

On the second night the ayahuasca tasted terrible, like the entire jungle had shit into my mouth. The first sign of intoxication came in the form of a ticking sound. Next, I felt that there was a seam being stitched into my face. The seam was not painful, but something was tugging at it, the same entity that was making the ticking noise, and as the ticking noise increased, the tension also increased. When I imagined my face, in my mind’s eye, it was blank, no features, not even skin, covered with thick stocking fabric. I searched in vain for the part of my brain that could remind me this was not real. What was my name? What was the name of this scary drug I was on? 

The ticking sound turned into the sound of rustling feathers. I sat up, trying not to give in to the Medicine, but then I had to lie down. The rustling went on and on, for hours, and I saw nothing but dirty feathers, broken plates and cutlery and swatches of fabric, refrigerator interiors and bathroom tiles and grandmothers’ wheelchairs and enema bags and pill containers and tomato egg timers and Pet Rocks from homes I’d been to in elementary school.

more here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.