Potatoes and Poison Hemlock: The Landscape of American Politics

by Mark Harvey

Vivek Ramaswamy

The first time I ever saw Vivek Ramaswamy, the guy who ran for both president and governor of Ohio, I had the same primal reaction I get when I see a poisonous plant: don’t eat that, don’t elect that. It was one of those early presidential debates, and there were a number of toxic plants up on stage—Ron DeSantis, Nikki Haley, Tim Scott, etc.—but I was already familiar with their necrotic personalities. Ramaswamy was a little different: smoother, younger, better hair. Thus it was hard to put a finger on my immediate revulsion to his presence.

In the parsley family, two plants look alike: poison hemlock and wild carrots. But eating one will kill you through respiratory paralysis, while eating the other, with its beta-carotene, may just improve your eyesight. I’m afraid that some American voters are just terrible botanists when it comes to politics and often mistake someone as poisonous as Ramaswamy for a perfectly good carrot. It’s to be forgiven in some cases when a politician is particularly good at camouflaging their snake oil. Most of us by a certain age have been disappointed by a double-dealing politician. But to repeatedly vote for men and women who are genetically slimy and dishonest is not forgivable. It’s just stupid and reckless.

Poison Hemlock

Which brings us to the most carrot-colored man on the planet, someone I hope will soon go the way of compost: silent, damp, and harmless. Not far down the road, we can be free of hearing the name Donald Trump and be free of all his jackals and jackasses. As so many wags have put it on social media, the 2024 election was an open-book exam. The orange man had shown his colors throughout his entire first presidency, and his inability to accept defeat in 2020, yet Americans reelected him. Heck, the 2016 election was an open-book exam for anyone who had followed Trump’s career as the developer who didn’t pay his subcontractors or the casino operator who somehow managed to go bankrupt. After getting through the permitting process, how do you go bankrupt with a casino? They’re basically fancy buildings with mathematical guarantees that the fools who enter the casino will leave several dollars poorer, the house several dollars richer. Yet through some epically stupid financing, Trump managed to bankrupt all four of his casinos.

The recent midterms and the blue tsunami are effectively the end of MAGA. The rats are already repositioning themselves, rewriting history, and jumping ship. Megyn Kelly, that epiphytic sponge root, is shamelessly repositioning herself as a critic of the current administration.  How does someone so good at layering on her makeup think we won’t notice her two faces? Actually, her mastery of hiding her real face with eyeliner, blush, and contouring kind of answers that question. Ron DeSantis, whose given name is Metopium Toxiferum, embodies a profile in courage by waiting until Texas turned blue to turn coat.

We have some exceptionally promising politicians entering Congress, and there have been some historic choices made by American voters on the state level too. You could start in Texas with the election of its first-ever Latina governor-elect, Gina Hinojosa. As a state legislator, Hinojosa authored the Fully Fund Our Future Act, which was meant to add $40 billion to the Texas Public Schools and give teachers a $15,000 pay raise. Governor Abbot kept the bill from ever going to a vote with his control of the agenda. Abbot wanted a bill to increase school vouchers for private schools. Those opposing priorities perfectly capture why Hinojosa won, and Abbot lost.

In neighboring New Mexico, voters elected the country’s first-ever Native American to be governor. Deb Haaland, Secretary of the Interior under the Biden Administration, won by a whopping 14 percentage points. She ran on various issues but emphasized fighting federal rollbacks of environmental protections, especially regarding energy development in the Permian Basin. New Mexico gets a lot of oil and gas from the  Permian Basin, and the place is a toxic mix of radon plumes, ozone, and volatile organic compounds. Her opponent, Greg Hull, ran on deregulating the oil and gas industry. In one of the most beautiful states of the Union, maybe New Mexicans wanted a guv less keen on air choked with benzene.

Troy Jackson

One of my favorite victories was that of Troy Jackson in Maine. If Vivek Ramaswami is poison hemlock disguised as a carrot, Troy Jackson is definitely a potato who doesn’t pretend to be anything but a potato. Potatoes are those wonderful vegetables that can be planted early in the spring before the last frost, thrive in nearly any soil, and not fuss about the timing of their harvest. Once harvested, they last months if stored properly. They can make it through the better part of a cold, hard winter if stored in a good cellar.

Troy Jackson has zero bling, and zero effect. He is not the soft-handed politician who goes to a county fair wearing a checked shirt and Carhartts to try to appear “rural” and win the farmer’s vote. A logger by trade, you can kind of tell by his face and bearing that he’s fixed a hundred chainsaws, skidded thousands of trees out of the forest, and fought with any number of diesel trucks. I’m going to guess his wardrobe is largely made up of checked shirts because he is a fifth-generation logger from the town of Allagash in Aroostook County. Jackson is a pretty terrible debater and has the charisma of a root vegetable. I don’t say that disparagingly because if you come to know potatoes, there’s something quite appealing (sorry) about them, something deeply grounded.

Jackson is as unpolished as Ramaswamy is slick. He has a funny accent that I’ve wondered about because I spent enough time in New England as a student to recognize the typical Maine accent, and Jackson’s accent is all over the map. I stumbled on a linguist on YouTube who broke down Jackson’s speech, and this is what he concluded: his peculiar speech came from five generations of his family growing up on a very isolated island of English-speaking people more than a hundred miles north of Montreal, surrounded by people who spoke only Acadian French. So he has a touch of Maine, a touch of Canada, and maybe a touch of Acadian. With American English being flattened and homogenized by the Internet, it’s refreshing and charming to hear a person speak in ways that go back to the 1800s.

Lauren Boebert

I promise these botanical parallels will wilt and die soon, but indulge me for one more: Lauren Boebert. To many of us Coloradans, Boebert’s appearance on the political scene was about as welcome as an infestation of cheat grass or leafy spurge. There are many words to describe weeds, but one of the most common is noxious. Noxious means physically or morally harmful, and obnoxious means rude, annoying, and unpleasant. Boebert manages to be both. What we know about weeds is that they are opportunistic, choke out more desirable plants, and are hard to get rid of. Boebert embodies all those lovely qualities with her shrill, bracing, attention-seeking personality.

I can’t seem to conjure a political parallel between spraying the herbicide glyphosate on thistles and what looks like finally ridding Colorado’s political scene of Boebert. Still, there is a pretty good analogy in the plant world: autotoxicity. It’s not a perfect analogy, but plants like alfalfa sometimes ooze toxic chemicals, including medicarpin, that poison surrounding plants to ensure their own survival. The result is what farmers call “soil sickness,” and it makes it impossible to successfully plant the same crop on that land without some sort of crop rotation. Boebert is about as auto-toxic as they come, and it led to her losing the race to a Democrat in Colorado’s ever-red fourth district. That’s a beautiful crop rotation!

Troy Jackson showed up in Washington last week for the Senate orientation wearing a suit from Target that lists for $89. It looks like a perfectly good suit, and it looks good on him. I have a feeling one of those Italian suits, like a Brioni, would make him itch. You can practically hear him equating the price of such a suit to the purchase of four brand-new chainsaws or enough hydraulic oil for several years. A tuber through and through.

Pick your metaphor. Our wonderful country was nearly defoliated by the Agent Orange in the White House or reduced to hives and a red rash from a poison-ivy cabinet. May the cool blue wave that came on November third give us the relief we so badly need. In a world of poisonous hemlock, we need more potatoes.