The Midas Machine
by Katalin Balog In a recent bestseller, Eliezer Yudkowsky and Nate Soares argue that artificial superintelligence (ASI), if it is ever built, will wipe out humanity. Unsurprisingly, this idea has gotten a lot of attention. People want to know if humanity has finally gotten around to producing an accurate prophecy of impending doom. The argument…
Resistance and Resistance
by Katalin Balog “…eventually he regained his balance and dismissed all thought of resistance from his mind, and concentrated on accepting the dizzy state of the world that was spinning round him as a perfectly natural state of affairs…” —László Krasznahorkai, The Melancholy of Resistance (trans. George Szirtes) I grew up in communist Hungary, the…
God, the Devil, and the Singularity
Can We Still Have a Soul?
by Katalin Balog It was the first day of a Tibetan Buddhist retreat in 2016. We were about to participate in a ritual of chants and burning sage. Before we proceeded outside, the head teacher asked all of us to invite someone we would like to share this moment with. Instantly and vividly, my grandfather…
Machine as Mirror: The Undoing of the Human Image
by Katalin Balog Nathaniel in E. T. A. Hoffmann’s The Sandman loses his sanity over having fallen in love with a wooden doll, the beautiful automaton Olympia. Olympia is an invention of a mad scientist and a master of the dark arts. Like Mary Shelley’s monster, born of the romantic imagination, she is the first…
The Rise and Fall of the Mind-Body Problem
by Katalin Balog The mind-body problem in its current form – an inquiry into how the mind fits into the physical universe – was formulated by René Descartes in the 17th century. In his Meditations, a thin volume of philosophy that had a monumental effect on all later Western philosophy, he famously argued that it…
Virtual Alienation
by Katalin Balog In the past, when I asked students if they would want to enter the Experience Machine – a fictional contraption thought up by the philosopher Robert Nozick – they would generally say no. In the Experience Machine, one would have virtual experiences: for example, of a life blessed with mountains of pleasure,…
Contemplation in Retreat
by Katalin Balog If the doors of perception were cleansed every thing would appear to man as it is, Infinite. For man has closed himself up, till he sees all things thro’ narrow chinks of his cavern. —William Blake, The Marriage of Heaven and Hell Laments about young people’s declining mental health, their inability to…
The Death and Life of a Great Garden
What Is Left of the Mind
The Brain’s I: the great intermingling
The man of the hour
by Katalin Balog "As he died to make man holy, let us die to make things cheap." –Leonard Cohen, "Steer your way" In this article I use a distinction borrowed from philosophy, between objectivity and subjectivity, to look at the nature of the Trump presidency. I explicated that distinction in more detail in some earlier…
A crack in everything
by Katalin Balog There is a crack, a crack in everything That's how the light gets in.(Leonard Cohen, “Anthem”) *This essay, on the personal in politics, is written in lieu of the final instalment of The Brain’s I, a series I have been publishing here on the subjective/objective divide in our lives and thought. The…
The brain’s I: the self in action
The brain’s I: science and the lived world
The brain’s I
An inconsistent triad: Trump, Sanders, Clinton, and the radical mismatch in the theater of politics
by Katalin Balog I. Trump In the last 30 years, I have witnessed, criss-crossing the Atlantic, first, my native Hungary's transition from communism to democracy and capitalism, and, for the past 6, its about-face: the sudden dismantling of the institutional system of liberal democracy, as well as the rapid spread of crony capitalism, the establishment…
