Skip to content

Sign up for a small monthly payment and enjoy ads-free browsing at 3QD


3 Quarks Daily

Make a one-time donation and enjoy ads-free browsing at 3QD


  • Home
  • About Us
  • Monday Magazine
  • Archives
  • Support 3QD
  • Log In

Hartosh Singh Bal

Hartosh Singh Bal

Hartosh has an undergraduate degree in mechanical engineering from BITS Pilani, India and a graduate degree in mathematics from New York University. None of this was meant as preparation for a career in journalism but he is now political editor of the weekly magazine Open that comes out of New Delhi. He is also co-author of a A Certain Ambiguity: A Mathematical Novel brought out by Princeton University Press. Email: [email protected]

The search for a two-thousand-year-old city

Posted on Monday, Feb 6, 2012 12:05AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal Lost to history, a number of cities of classical antiquity once existed along the banks of the river Narmada in central India. Many of these cities date back to the 3rd century BC, to the time of the emperor Ashoka, who united the subcontinent into an empire whose extent was never…

Leave a comment

The cost of democracy

Posted on Monday, Jan 2, 2012 12:30AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal Time Magazine declared it the year of the protester, clubbing together what was happening in regions as different as the Arab world, the US and India. While it is easy to find commonalities among the young, urban and largely middle-class protesters who came out on the streets, in some cases they…

Leave a comment

At home with Osho

Posted on Monday, Dec 5, 2011 12:20AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal The West came to know him in the sixties. The children of parents who had lived through a world war wanted no part of the old answers. With their disdain for everything their parents stood for, they searched for easy answers elsewhere. Among those offering such answers was this man named…

Leave a comment

The problems of pluralism

Posted on Monday, Nov 7, 2011 12:40AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal Two recent events, the removal of an essay on the many tellings of the Indian epic the Ramayana from the curriculum of Delhi University and the firebombing of a French newspaper for printing a cartoon of the Prophet in an edition devoted to a satirical look at the Shariat, share a…

Leave a comment

Romancing the Revolution

Posted on Monday, Oct 10, 2011 12:45AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal Sixty-five years or so after India’s independence, conflicts that question the idea of a constitutional republic do not show any signs of dying down. A few deservedly get some attention, such as the one in Kashmir. The others, for instance the events in the northeast, hardly get noticed in the rest…

Leave a comment

The problem with the Indian media and why you should care

Posted on Monday, Sep 12, 2011 12:40AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal In 1977 an Australian media tycoon changed the world of cricket. His name was Kerry Packer, but in his approach to life and business there was little to separate him from Rupert Murdoch. Before Packer intervened, a game of cricket lasted five days, was played by players wearing white and required…

Leave a comment

The Problems of Victimhood

Posted on Monday, Aug 15, 2011 8:42AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal Somewhere near the town of Renala Khurd in Pakistan is a patch of land (a morabba to be exact) that once belonged to my family. In lieu of this land, through a series of land transfers, complicated but no more complicated than the history of the division of the subcontinent, my…

Leave a comment

The hallucinogenic meaning of mantras

Posted on Monday, Jul 18, 2011 1:00AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal For a tradition that seems to extend back to the Harappan civilization, our lack of knowledge of some key aspects of Indic religions continues to be baffling. One problem, of course is our inability to unlock the world of the Harappans. Signage and seals are available in large number but so…

Leave a comment

The Absence of Ambedkar

Posted on Monday, May 23, 2011 12:10AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal At a recent lunch with a writer from the US, discussing our common interest in rivers, I asked him what had led to his new project. He told me that he had first visited India several years ago and had toyed with several ideas, one involved travelling through the forested areas…

Leave a comment

Kids Stuff

Posted on Monday, Apr 25, 2011 12:38AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal Like so many others in India, I grew up on tales from the Mahabharata and the Ramayana and the books of Enid Blyton. Well produced children’s books with an Indian context were rare, and now looking back I’m not sure as children we needed such a context. Most children’s books are…

Leave a comment

The Ramanujan of Chess

Posted on Monday, Feb 28, 2011 12:40AMSunday, January 20, 2019 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal The perils of writing about Ramanujan, as I did in my last 3QD column, is that there will always be those who insist that a better educated Ramanujan would have been a worse mathematician. One response is to say that by the same token a worse educated Euler would have been…

Leave a comment

The use and misuse of Srinivasa Ramanujan

Posted on Monday, Jan 31, 2011 1:00AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

by Hartosh Singh Bal Over the past month there have been two separate reasons to return to the story of Srinivasa Ramanujan. The first was the result of an astounding piece of mathematics by Ken Ono and his colleagues on the theory of partitions, bringing to a conclusion some of Ramanujan’s most interesting work in…

Leave a comment

Why I can’t even get my mother to agree with me on homeopathy

Posted on Monday, Jan 3, 2011 12:15AMFriday, December 8, 2017 by Hartosh Singh Bal

Last month, late at night, searching for a painkiller for my wife I came upon an old stock of tablets I had been prescribed for a muscle injury. It was a combination peculiar to India, and among other drugs it included Paracetamol and Diclofenac. Since she was still breastfeeding I took care to check the…

Leave a comment

Receive 3QD Posts by Email

Please fill out the form below to get our email with all the posts from the previous 24 hours, which is sent out a bit after midnight (NY City time) each day. This is completely free of charge for everyone.
Name: 
Your email address:*
Please wait...
Please enter all required fields Click to hide
Correct invalid entries Click to hide

Coronavirus COVID-19 Info

PLEASE CLICK HERE.

Search 3QD



Follow 3QD on Social Media


What People Say About 3QD




"Just wanted you to know I’m one of many who reads and enjoys 3 Quarks....almost daily."

—David Byrne, musician, former lead-singer of the Talking Heads, artist, intellectual.




"For sheer elegance, wit and worldly wisdom when it comes to reading, editing, presenting the real news of the world... for liveliness, cosmopolitanism, range of scientific, philosophical, and literary curiosity in harvesting big and provocative ideas... for consistency of character and manners, ever above the ordinary... 3 Quarks stands alone. If 3 Quarks Daily were a person, wouldn't it be Proust?"

—Christopher Lydon, host of the excellent show "Open Source" on National Public Radio, author, media personality.




"I have placed 3 Quarks Daily at the head of my list of web bookmarks."

—Richard Dawkins, previously Charles Simonyi Professor of the Public Understanding of Science at Oxford University.




"3 Quarks Daily is terrific - many congratulations, and many thanks!"

—Alain de Botton, best-selling Swiss-British writer and Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature.




"3 Quarks Daily is one of the most interesting aggregator blogs out there. It puts together stuff from art, science, philosophy, politics, literature. It’s a completely international, cosmopolitan place to get information. It’s become my entry point to reading on the Web."

—Mohsin Hamid, author of Moth Smoke, The Reluctant Fundamentalist, and How to Get Filthy Rich in Rising Asia, in the New York Times.




"3 Quarks is a daily must-read for intellectuals of all stripes. It is perhaps even smarter and better and more comprehensive than Arts & Letters Daily, the de facto gold standard of the smart set on the internet."

—Laura Claridge, former Professor of English at the U.S. Naval Academy, and author of Romantic Potency: The Paradox of Desire, Tamara de Lempicka: A Life of Deco and Decadence, and Norman Rockwell: A Life.




"It is a great honor to be mentioned in one of my two ONLY portals to the internet—and the world, since I do not read newspapers. My discipline, to avoid drowning in information, is not to cruise the web outside of these two points. I tried many sites; yours has CHARM."

—Nassim Nicholas Taleb, author of Fooled by Randomness and The Black Swan. [The other site NNT is referring to is the excellent Arts & Letters Daily.]




"3 Quarks Daily is smart and highclass."

—Robert Pinsky, only three-term U.S. Poet Laureate.




"I look at your site every day. It's where the two cultures meet."

—Suketu Mehta, author of Pulitzer Prize finalist Maximum City, winner of the O. Henry Prize, and frequent contributor to various newspapers and magazines.




"Thanks for 3 Quarks Daily which has been very high on my reading list for several years now!"

—Huw Price, Bertrand Russell Professor of Philosophy and Fellow of Trinity College at the University of Cambridge. He is also co-founder, with Martin Rees and Jaan Tallinn, of a project to establish a Centre for the Study of Existential Risk.






Recent Comments on 3QD

  • Michael Sorokin So technology is going to solve a problem it created by doing more of the same? Okay. That sounds like a form of insanity to me, but whatever, we are...

    ‘It is the question of the century’: will tech solve the climate crisis – or make it worse? ·  Saturday, March 6, 2021

  • Charlie Huenemann What a marvelously lucid lecture!

    Ludwig Wittgenstein (A. C. Grayling) ·  Saturday, March 6, 2021

  • Android Pitanga Whether his guess is as accurate as any, that may be, but it's certainly more interesting and well developed than many.

    Philosopher Nick Bostrom’s “singleton hypothesis” predicts the future of human societies ·  Saturday, March 6, 2021

  • SloMo2020 How fitting that the essay which follows this is ......

    How Democrats are already letting Republicans win in 2022 ·  Friday, March 5, 2021

  • Julia I love this article.

    Accidental Adventures in Immunology ·  Friday, March 5, 2021

  • Michael Sorokin Predictions about the future are a mug's game. This guy's guess is as good as anyone's.

    Philosopher Nick Bostrom’s “singleton hypothesis” predicts the future of human societies ·  Friday, March 5, 2021

  • Bill Benzon The Biden Administration has appointed Tim Wu to the...

    Down the Rabbit Hole With Schubert and Hawley ·  Friday, March 5, 2021

  • Michael Liss It's just a little bit early to start writing political obituaries? Yes, culture wars are important, but voters might also be interested in actual...

    How Democrats are already letting Republicans win in 2022 ·  Friday, March 5, 2021

  • Ken_Pidcock So the thesis is that Republicans are able to exploit culture war issues because Democrats won't eliminate the filibuster. And this is because, if...

    How Democrats are already letting Republicans win in 2022 ·  Friday, March 5, 2021

  • PhilipGraham Well, THAT was a rewarding search. It turns out Rufus Harley recorded a bagpipes jazz version of “Eight Miles High,” one of my favorite songs by...

    Confessions of an Accordion Addict ·  Friday, March 5, 2021

  • PhilipGraham I know! There’s jazz violin (which I love), jazz harp (Alice Coltrane and more), jazz harmonica (which we now all know is but a small one quarter...

    Confessions of an Accordion Addict ·  Friday, March 5, 2021

  • Bill Benzon Thanks for this, Philip. Yes, I heard Lawrence Welk in my youth. Now that I think of it, it was schizy experience. The music itself seemed pretty...

    Confessions of an Accordion Addict ·  Thursday, March 4, 2021

  • Chris Horner Scientific truth is itself part of a set of procedures - as you describe - that provide a warrant or justification for claims (as pragmatists say)....

    Truth, Lies and Pragmatism ·  Thursday, March 4, 2021

  • Mike W Wouldn't this create massive levels of micro-plastic pollution?

    Could plastic roads make for a smoother ride? ·  Thursday, March 4, 2021

  • S Herb I agree with this demystification of 'free will' . I am still of the opinion that the traditional association of free will with religious decisions...

    Daniel C. Dennett: Herding Cats and Free Will Inflation ·  Wednesday, March 3, 2021

  • Michael Liss I hesitate to reply....

    Down the Rabbit Hole With Schubert and Hawley ·  Wednesday, March 3, 2021

  • Ofinfinitejest . You will never read a better or more insightful philosophical essay than this one. His concern about why we may well not want to create artificial...

    Daniel C. Dennett: Herding Cats and Free Will Inflation ·  Wednesday, March 3, 2021

  • Brooks Riley And a few hours after I posted that comment above, an ad for sheet music appeared on an internet article I was reading. . . (cue music for The...

    Down the Rabbit Hole With Schubert and Hawley ·  Wednesday, March 3, 2021

  • Brooks Riley Kitty Carlisle was the Merry Widow in a 1943 Broadway production. A marvelous English-language version. As a child, I used to lip-synch in front of...

    Confessions of an Accordion Addict ·  Wednesday, March 3, 2021

  • Michael Liss The WSJ is reporting this morning that Alphabet, parent company of Google, said it plans next year to stop using or investing in tracking technologies...

    Down the Rabbit Hole With Schubert and Hawley ·  Wednesday, March 3, 2021

  • Sue Plenty of things have tested positive to the PCR test. That's why it's unfit for purpose. Look, here's an epidemic it misdiagnosed earlier:...

    The search for animals harbouring coronavirus — and why it matters ·  Wednesday, March 3, 2021

  • Michael Liss Brooks, to your point, the algorithm now seems to think I want a concealed carry holster. Unless it it has a deeper insight into my needs than my...

    Down the Rabbit Hole With Schubert and Hawley ·  Wednesday, March 3, 2021

  • Michael Liss Kitty Carlisle was a panelist on To Tell The Truth. Also an occasional opera singer, Broadway and film actress and worked in government. I don't...

    Confessions of an Accordion Addict ·  Wednesday, March 3, 2021

  • Jochen Szangolies Very interesting argument. I like the 'tools' picture---I have occasionally thought in terms of interfaces: our attempts at conceptualizing the world...

    Pragmatism as philosophical tool design ·  Wednesday, March 3, 2021

  • PhilipGraham Thank you, Dave. A real compliment, as you have two of the best ears out there.

    Confessions of an Accordion Addict ·  Wednesday, March 3, 2021

  • Sally Benzon Excellent question. Hospital administrators and insurance companies have much more data to draw from in their decisions about hospital management,...

    Down the Rabbit Hole With Schubert and Hawley ·  Tuesday, March 2, 2021

  • Bill Benzon I’ve been listening to these clips again because, well, she’s just so damn good. One thing I noticed is that, not only does she employ a range...

    Sukiyaki and beyond: Hiromi Uehara, music, war and peace, Chick Corea, and others ·  Tuesday, March 2, 2021

  • Michael Liss Passing this one on to close friend in Baltimore. He won't agree with the politics, but he'll enjoy the local color.

    Epilog: Peace and Horror ·  Tuesday, March 2, 2021

  • David Jauss Another beaut, Philip!

    Confessions of an Accordion Addict ·  Tuesday, March 2, 2021

  • Jim Harrison George Soros' theory of market behavior amounts to an application of Girard's central concept of mimetic rivalry to high finance.

    Chatting With René Girard ·  Tuesday, March 2, 2021

3QD Design History and Credits

The original site was designed by S. Abbas Raza in 2004 but soon completely redesigned by Mikko Hyppönen and deployed by Henrik Rydberg. It was later upgraded extensively by Dan Balis in 2006. The next major revision was designed by S. Abbas Raza, building upon the earlier look, and coded by Dumky de Wilde in 2013. And this current version 5.0 has been designed and deployed by Dumky de Wilde in collaboration with S. Abbas Raza.

3 Quarks Daily

3 Quarks Daily started in 2004 with the idea of creating a curated retreat for everything intellectual on the web. No clickbait, no fake news, not just entertainment, but depth and breadth —something increasingly hard to find on the internet today. If you like what we do, please consider making a donation.