America and Empire: Thoughts on a Debate
![](http://3quarksdaily.blogs.com/3quarksdaily/images/2007/06/11/screenhunter_02_jun_11_1025_2.gif)
by Alex Cooley In a recent issue of Foreign Affairs, Alex Motyl posed the question, “Do past empires hold lessons for U.S. foreign policy today?” In a review of two new books (an edited volume by Craig Calhoun and a study by Charles Maier), he concluded that “efforts [to show that they do] yield little…