Talk to the Animals

Barbara J. King at Literary Review:

Some years ago, a prominent animal-behaviour scientist hosted a colleague at his field station devoted to the study of chimpanzees. Talking together on top of the observation tower, the pair glanced at the apes but mostly stayed absorbed in conversation. Then a female chimpanzee named Thai began to scream and hit herself in dramatic fashion. In response to her outburst, other chimpanzees rushed to embrace, hold and kiss her.

Now the colleagues’ attention was riveted on the primates below. ‘I immediately realised,’ the scientist later wrote, ‘why she was making such a fuss. Whenever I visited the tower, I always greeted Thai with hand gestures and a few friendly Dutch words, but this time I’d neglected to do so.’ Only when he greeted her ‘profusely’ did the chimpanzee begin to calm down. In some animal-­behaviour circles even today, this interpretation of Thai’s tantrum would be met with a sneer and charges of anthropomorphism: the scientist must be projecting onto the ape the feelings of neglect and distress a human might experience in response to a perceived snub from an old friend. Bad form, sceptics say; such an anecdote carries no scientific value.

more here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.