An Eternity of Digital Effluvia

by Peter Topolewski

Jacob’s Ladder by William Blake

Not all things in moderation are “good”. Murder, for instance. But many things done in moderation feel good, such as eating, drinking, shopping, gambling, drugs, being well organized. In these activities, and others like them, there is a line between moderation and excess. The line, though, is fuzzy, and if you’re caught up in one of these kinds of things, you can’t always detect which side you’re on or how far you’ve gone. Your power to discern and discriminate withers to the point you don’t recognize the harm you cause yourself and others. Your ability to reason mutates, especially in arguments with yourself, and you become very convincing in a twisted logic sort of way.

That gambling debt is a debt I can gamble my way out of.

My cocaine use is a problem I can address after I snort this rail.

My self-improvement obsession will moderate once I learn to structure my life better.

At this stage, the joy in these once enjoyable activities is gone. They’ve become chores, and the high they provided, in diminishing returns, is approaching zero.

With the benefit of objectivity—that is, when we have the opportunity to see someone else fall into this predicament—obsessively pursued activities look like madness. We watch, sometimes not with sympathy but with curiosity or even morbid glee, lives that have become trainwrecks. Remember the TV shows about hoarders? We marvel at the how and why of piling clothes or Tupperware to the ceiling in every room of the house, the obscenity and grossness of it.

If you’re at a point in life where you are preparing or updating your will, a good lawyer will tell you that while you’re at it, prepare your digital legacy. Why? To hand off your online bank accounts, your Instagram and Facebook, Bluesky, Truth Social, the alarm system log in, the passwords to a hundred different websites. Decide who gets control when you’re gone, and if no one, then take note that your online life could persist well beyond your expiration, perhaps even give the impression years after your funeral that you’re still with us.

Be aware, however, that there is an online legacy you don’t control so well, one you can’t bequeath so easily. This “you” is tough to define and envisage. It is the you of your saved preferences, documents, accounts, purchase histories, locations, tweets, photos, posted articles, emails, and so on. These dwell in servers and backups of servers, and they are in the hard drives of those you shared them with, on the servers of companies that host the accounts of those you shared them with, and in copies of copies. Your data is smeared across these platforms and stamped, for tracking and syncing purposes, with cryptic inscriptions most of us could never decipher.

Now, it is true that long after we have departed this Earth, a portion of our digital lives will also die what we, in this context at least, consider a natural death. Links will break. Our personal details will eventually get chopped up and sold off in little bits at a discount, the collectanea of our lives will decompose and become unidentifiable as “ours”. A slow and silent sayonara.

How do technology companies build such a “you”? By making our data the price we pay for their help. Help at what? Taking photos, copying text, highlighting snippets of documents, stashing articles in read-later apps, opening dozens of tabs in multiple browsers, writing in digital notebooks, building libraries of music files, bookmarking websites and videos, recording likes, building to-do lists, posting comments, compiling courses to take one day, sharing documents with others, having others share with you, and on it goes. Online tools make it so easy to collect and compile—for what, exactly?

To build an online presence. To express your opinions. To connect. There are myriad other reasons we’re captivated by these tools, not all of them pleasant. We can get obsessive in our use, and the line between healthy and unhealthy gets even fuzzier in this realm than the offline. But amidst all the regrettable uses of these tech tools, there are noble causes, too. Many are small, nothing more than an itch to scratch. Maybe it’s a song you’re writing. Or a program you’re coding, a trip you’re documenting, a recipe book you’re writing.

Interestingly, the technology you’re using is not functionally different from the pen and paper some of us have been alive long enough to remember using to capture information. But there are differences. Libraries and attics around the world stuffed with printed documents attest that the digital age was not the start of this form of hoarding—but once we’ve gone to the afterlife, the majority of us will undoubtedly have left more digital files than paper ones. This is, after all, not the age of moderation. That, combined with the fact that paper is more tangible, and in some cases more romantic, suggests there is a greater likelihood the dear people you leave behind will browse through the handwritten letters you stashed in a box than they will click through the snippets of your digital storehouse and discover your hidden obsessions and unappreciated genius. Maybe that’s a good thing.

The heft of the digital artifacts we can keep probably makes us lazier than in the old days. Meaning most of your emails are not epistles, most of your photos are not waiting to be discovered by National Geographic. But the technology is also about opening to all of us opportunities to write and photograph and make music. And in the digital age, entire ecosystems to save, share, backup, and sync this gathered media and knowledge have bloomed, along with those to organize and reorganize it, to streamline it and mind map it, to access and search it from anywhere, to tag it and repackage it in tables and databases, and to “put it to use” to “get things done” (GTD). To be sure, compared to pen and paper the learning curve with such apps is much greater, which can send you on prolonged searches for alternative platforms that delay your grand project. But in some form, you persist, because collecting another like or another GIF is as simple as tapping a button.

The ease with which we save lists of books and articles read, movies watched, inspired thoughts dreamt up means, yes, we are probably all digital hoarders. But mixed in with the inevitable dreck we archive, the construction of your digital “you” is also about the pursuit of empowerment and knowledge and inspiration and creativity. Among the piles of digital detritus you collected, obscenely like a hoarder, this “you” is a treasure.

In days past, the paper you scribbled your plans and thoughts and stories on could be lost or eaten by a dog, or as the novelist Ralph Ellison learned—burned up in a fire. Not so today. At least in theory. The irony is that the digital “you” that you create can disappear much quicker than the one technology companies assemble behind the scenes. The reason is simple: you have embarked on your journey of digital accumulation and organization on platforms you don’t understand, not functionally, technologically, or legally. We can deploy these tools so easily without appreciating their weaknesses, restrictions, and price, the bugginess of their code, the use cases not anticipated, and the precarity of the companies running them.

When the technology hiccups or the company pivots or shutters or gets bought, the loss is not fanciful. It’s not the same as failing to make sense of an audio-message-to-self that you recorded in a moment of psychedelic inspiration—unintelligible and, when sober, clearly unintelligent. The loss of a digital scrapbook or an ongoing video project is not frustrating. It is a gut punch.

Most of us do not have Ellison’s talent, and in all likelihood none of us have lost, as he did, pages of a follow-up to a novel like Invisible Man. For us, the cherished work that goes irretrievably missing in a software glitch or a hardware malfunction might be a family photo collage, a digital painting, beats to a new song, or notes on a poem. It is devastating. You can wrack your brain for the details, the brush strokes you made or the web pages you saved, the turn of a phrase you used. You can take some comfort acknowledging that of course a portion of your “hoard” that disappeared was surely headed for the slag heap. But it contained jewels, too, ones you won’t recapture. They came in instances of magic, the moments where time and energy and insight aligned. The pain you feel at their loss is the fear, the knowledge, those elements won’t—can’t—ever align again, not that way. A few details might come back, but not all, you won’t re-create what you did in the past.

The heartbreak of losing such a project stems, perhaps, from the fact that these notes and outlines and sketches represented potential, a future you you were working toward. At times, you did so avidly and at others probably only after great bouts of procrastination. Through it all, you were not looking ahead to more of the same, you were looking ahead to a better you.

What to do?

Mourn. Feel sorry for yourself. Move on.

The novelist Lauren Groff might have the ultimate “moving on” strategy. It sounds sadomasochistic, but her writing technique entails shoving each draft of her novel in a banker box and rewriting the whole thing from memory, thereby (the theory goes) sharpening it and bringing out the best bits. For everyone else, moving on from the loss of our digital “you” might include going analog, collecting less, backing up more, spending more time offscreen and in nature, pursuing your hobby in greater moderation, focusing more intently on the present or only one aspect of life rather than suffocating under a million possibilities.

We also have the option to better steel ourselves for more turmoil. On our current trajectory, there is about to be more, not less, of our lives online than ever. At the high end of the tech enthusiast scale, you’ll find mourners who have collected the online leftovers of their dead spouses or parents or friends. Not to stir memories, but to build chatbots they can type with when the mood strikes. Yes, imagine your digital “you” assembled from the length and depth of your text messages, carrying on as your avatar into eternity, or at least as long as the server lights stay on.

In the not too distant future, your digital “you” could be an entirely different creature. If we get to extend our lives by uploading our brains to the cloud—and that is a dream among the priests of Silicon Valley—we might get to roam to the ends of the metaverse and, who knows, the regular universe, too. We might have the chance to bathe in endless streams of AI-generated content, and perhaps there, in an eternity of digital effluvia, strive for a better version of ourselves.

In this future, your better self could be gone the moment the firm hosting your brain gets bought and repurposed. Your loved ones still living an analog life need to be prepared for the gut punch of your disappearance, announced via email, a you who was “there” and then suddenly not, ones and zeroes evaporated into the once was. At that point, mourners won’t be much further ahead than on the day of your funeral. They’d be better off following Groff’s daring example, carving from their memories the best “you” they can recall.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.