A Politics of Essentials

Isabella Weber in Phenomenal World:

For decades, mainstream economics has diverted attention away from the problems it cannot solve—even a problem as fundamental as survival. In the 1950s, economists researching general equilibrium theory set out to demonstrate that decentralized market decisions, guided only by prices, would lead to a “Pareto optimal” outcome (named for the turn-of-the-century Italian economist Vilfredo Pareto), in which “no redistribution of goods or productive resources can improve the position of one individual without making at least one other individual worse off.” But they ran into the so-­called survival problem: the same general equilibrium deemed socially optimal cannot guarantee that all people participating in the market can survive—­in technical terms, that they can afford a consumption bundle meeting minimum subsistence requirements. Yet this egregious inadequacy, identified long ago, did not stop the theory from taking hold as an orthodoxy.

An important lesson from the founder of equilibrium theory usually goes unmentioned: like Karl Polanyi, the nineteenth-­century economist Léon Walras believed that land—­the source of the most essential of essentials—­had to be in public hands for markets to work. Basically, this suggests that you need a form of socialism as the foundation for a functioning market economy, as markets presuppose a prior guarantee of subsistence that they cannot themselves provide. Polanyi thought that not just land, but also labor and money itself would need to be decommodified. Can this somewhat abstract principle be formulated into an economics that can directly inform policy strategy?

More here.

Enjoying the content on 3QD? Help keep us going by donating now.